My cousins and I went to a Sonoma wine tasting in New York comprising 20 vintners. Though I am American, it’s probably the region in the U.S. that I am least familiar with, falling behind even Oregon and Washington State.
I often discount a restaurant’s offerings of California’s wines assuming they are over-oaked, and over-priced. This particular tasting was not without a few of those stereotypical oaky Chardonnays, and even a few woody reds. As my cousin said about one of the wines at the tasting, “I feel like a termite.”
When we walked in to the Ana Tzarev Gallery, where the event was held, I recognized a few vineyards I had previously and had enjoyed, including Gary Farrell and Ferrari-Carano Vineyards, and I was excited to try their selections and share these with my cousins who had not tasted from these producers before. There were also plenty of the other representatives that are commonly found on store shelves and that we initially misinterpreted as capable of only producing low-end, jug wine.
Still, we were determined to keep open minds and unbiased palates for each vintner. Good thing because the true surprises came where we least expected.
My first lesson came in understanding the classic California Meritage. I’ve always enjoyed the blend, but I never fully comprehended what constitutes one. I quickly learned that a Meritage from California must comprise a mix of up-to seven varietals, only five of which grow in California. Those include Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Malbec, Cabernet Franc, and Petit Verdot. No single varietal may compose more than 90% of the wine. For a wine to compose those varietals and be labeled as a Cabernet Sauvignon, rather than a Meritage, it must contain a minimum of 75% of the grape.
Among our favorite expressions of the Meritage was the Ferrari-Carano Vineyards 2006 Trésor. Rodney Strong also poured a delightful blend, which is sold under the Symmetry label. The wine we tasted was a 2006. The Cyrus from Alexander Valley Vineyards was another Meritage that we enjoyed quite a lot. Bottles sell for around $75, $45 and $55, respectively.
Zinfandel was the next favorite of the group. Several producers showed some very solid examples, with the wines emanating notes of vanilla and tobacco. Acorn Winery showed a fantastic value in its 2007 selection, which sells for around $35. D’Argenzio Winery poured a 2004 Zin that was made from 100+ year-old vines and was quite enjoyable, while Deerfield Ranch poured two variations. One was under the Red Rex label and was mellow with little indication that it was aged in oak for 28 months. The second was made from old vines and was more bold, yet well balanced.
Our favorite value wine was from Alexander Valley Vineyards and was the 2007 Cabernet that sells for $20. 50,000 cases are made per year and the wine sees about 15 months in oak, though you would never know it from tasting it.
Yet, the most surprising wine of the night was consumed at Ravenswood’s table. There was a 2007 Icon, which comprises Carignan, Petit Verdot, Syrah, Zinfandel, and Mixed Blacks. The wine was amazing, and quite unexpected from a producer that we normally associate with under-$20 Zinfandel. The Icon sells for around $70.
There’s still much more I want to learn about this west coast region’s wines, but I walked out of the tasting more educated, and yes, more intoxicated, than when I walked in.